IRS Audit

GYST is Being Audited. How this works.

So, GYST along with myself and my full household are being audited. Since so many artists are being audited these days, I thought it might be useful to share the process so you can see what it is like to work with the IRS on an audit.

We were notified by the IRS with a letter as well as an email. We were asked to show up at a specific time (no choice of appointments) with a hand-full of paperwork. We were given a month to get all the following together.

2011 Tax return

2012 Tax return

2013 Tax return

All financial records, including bank statements, cancelled checks, receipts, the whole shebang.

So first, we contacted our Accountant, who happens to also know the laws regarding artists and creatives. He said that he would go to the first meeting with the IRS agent, but we would both need to sign a power of attorney. So we spent the next four weeks, gathering everything together. Luckily, we mostly have our sh*t together, so it was a matter of finding everything as well as printing out three years of accounting.

We signed a power of attorney, and our accountant went to the first meeting with the IRS.

We found out that recently, 100 people were hired at the IRS to look into business owners who used contracted labor. That means hiring another "business or business person" to do work for you. This is different than an employee. An employee works set hours, is required to be on site, and works regular hours for the business that hires them. An independent contractor is someone who has a business license and who works in their own office or home, and works on a contract to do a specific job. Over the years, GYST has hired other artists to work with us, as we usually have small jobs that don't require a full time person. We don't have enough work for a full time employee. (see the GYST website for more information on hiring at

The other reason, as a social business model and artist run art project, is that we train artists how to run their own businesses. We ask each artist who works with us to be self employed, have a business license, and invoice us for the hours worked, or the job as a whole. If we ever make enough money to hire someone full time, we would do that, but it is hard to find someone who actually knows every part of the business of business.

Things we hire artists for are editing, writing, programming, marketing, bookkeeping, teaching etc. We work as a team, but a team of independent artists.

So our accountant goes to the meeting armed with a big box of paperwork. We get an email from him yesterday that says we are required to answer the following questions for the IRS.

"The agent is going through her checklist of info questions to understand what you both do.  I thought I would email them to you to answer. Some items have been blacked out to protect the innocent and to keep some things private.

I am available to discuss these when you want.

1.       Did you record all sales receipts.

2.       Did you record all cash sales

3.       Do you have credit card receipts

4.       Do you receive checks  for payment.

5.       Do you transfer all paypal income to your  bank account as received. If not did you pick up all paypal income in then year received.

6.       Do you have anyone helping you with your bookkeeping?

7.       Can you explain what the individual people do ( the ones you 1099”ed)

8.       How long have you been working  at cal arts?

9.       How many hours a week do you work

10.   How many hours a week does ///  work.

11.   Did /// have anyone he 1099’ed

12.   Do you or /// invoice for your work . if not how do you let your customer know they owe you money

13.   What is the royality income from?

14.   Is Karen’s paycheck direct deposited?

15.   How long have you lived in your house

16.   Do you have more then two cars?

17.   Do either of you have a back ground in accounting?

18.   Do you pay your bills by check or credit cards? Or both . any cash payments

19.   Can you explain the what  following categories in Karen’s business are for ( brief description why you use these people ):

                     Accounting, marketing, programing.

20.   What is the income category “income provided”

21.   What do you mean when you call income  “resale Income”

22.   Karen can you resend the description of what GYST does. The one you sent did not come through.

23.   What was the expense diversified retirement of $/////// in 2012.

24.   If you or /// invoice can we get a copy of the invoice . also if you invoice how many invoices did you issue each in2012.

25.   How do you both market and get new business."

Of course, many of these answers were provided in the paperwork, if they had just looked at the accounting. And our accountant said this is the first time he has encountered all these questions.

The whole time I am thinking about all those corporations that are bleeding us dry and don't pay their share of taxes, and a tiny company of one artist and some helpers are getting audited. What is it about creatives that draws the IRS to audit us? We probably don't have any money to hire attorneys.

So far, we have spent over 20 hours, and that does not include answering questions. Time is money, so as a small company, the time is eating into our production, thereby making it harder for us to get things done.

I will keep you all posted as things go. We have one week to get these questions answered.

If anyone else has information on being audited, please share your stories. I think it is important to have some transparency as to how things work, which is the platform that GYSTInk is founded on. So sharing this information is part of the process of educating artists.

Written by GYSTInk Founder, Karen Atkinson